Customer Success Stories & Reviews

Discover exactly why we are the top-rated local tire shop and auto repair center in the Finger Lakes. Our unwavering commitment to honest pricing, expert workmanship, and stellar customer service has earned us the lasting loyalty of drivers throughout the entire region.

Write a Review for Your Location

reviews_hero

Hear From Our Satisfied Customers

Do not just take our word for it. Read real, verified reviews from Canandaigua drivers who consistently trust Murphy's Tire Service for all their crucial vehicle maintenance, complex auto repair needs, and fresh tire installations.

"These guys were awesome to work with. Very fair fast and car is driving like new!! They are my new go to mechanic!"

View Review

"I just want to give a HUGE HUGE HUGE shoutout to Tony!!! Many people come there because of YOU! Thank you for always being honest, fair and understanding. We ALL appreciate you and will continue to go to Murphys as long as your there. You really made a difference with Debbie. We ALL thank you!!!!"

View Review

"I can’t say enough about the amazing team at Murphy’s Tire Shop. I recently found myself in a tough spot—while I was in Western NY for a funeral, Hurricane Helene hit my hometown of Asheville, leaving debris everywhere. I knew I needed new tires for the trip home since so many people were damaging theirs on the rough roads. On the recommendation of friends who had gone to Murphy’s for years, I stopped in, and I’m so grateful that I did. Not only did the team at Murphy’s give me great advice on choosing durable tires, but they also recommended an oil change to ensure I was ready for the long drive. When I came back to pick up the car, I was blown away to find that they had filled it with food, water, medicine, and toiletries for me to take back to my neighbors impacted by the storm. To top it all off, they—along with Canandaigua Bank—covered the cost of the new tires and oil change. Their generosity and thoughtfulness were overwhelming, and they truly went above and beyond. If you’re looking for a tire shop that values its customers and treats them like family, Murphy’s Tire Shop is the place to go. Their kindness meant the world to me and my community in Western NC. Thank you, Murphy’s, for being such a blessing during a challenging time."

View Review

"No one else in town had availability or wanted to mount a set of tires I had onto my new 20" z28 camaro wheels. These guys didn't hesitate and did a great job, not a single scratch on the new wheels and at a fair price. I had them back and put back on the car in just a few hours. Just in time for the holiday weekend. Thank you"

View Review

Conveniently Located in Canandaigua

Murphy's Tire Service is centrally located in Canandaigua, NY, proudly serving our immediate neighbors and surrounding communities including Keuka Park, Branchport, Henrietta, Livonia, Rush, Naples, Penn Yan, Lyons, East Rochester, and Pittsford. Stop by our shop today for unbeatable automotive service.